Deepchecks LLM Evaluation: Testing Generative AI Applications
Deepchecks LLM evaluation brings the same testing mindset used for classic machine learning to applications built on large language models. Instead of trusting a handful of manual spot checks, teams score many interactions systematically and compare versions before and after release.
This article explains why LLM applications need structured testing, which qualities are usually evaluated, how a typical workflow runs and how to avoid the most common mistakes when building evaluation sets.
Why LLM Applications Need Structured Testing
Generative AI output is open-ended, so a single accuracy number rarely captures quality. One prompt change, model swap or retrieval tweak can improve some answers while quietly breaking others, and those regressions are hard to notice without a consistent evaluation set.
Structured evaluation means collecting representative inputs, running each application version against them, and scoring responses with repeatable criteria. That process turns subjective impressions into comparable results that product, data and engineering teams can discuss together.
What Gets Evaluated
Deepchecks describes its LLM product as a way to evaluate applications for quality, factuality, safety and reliability. Evaluations typically look at each interaction from several angles rather than giving one overall grade.
- Relevance: whether the answer addresses the user’s actual question.
- Grounding: whether a retrieval-based answer is supported by the provided context.
- Safety and tone: harmful, toxic or off-policy content.
- Completeness and fluency: clear, coherent and sufficiently detailed responses.
- Custom criteria: business rules that only your own team can define.
A Typical Evaluation Workflow
Work usually begins with an evaluation set of realistic inputs, often drawn from logs, support tickets or expert-written questions. Each candidate version of the application answers the same inputs so that differences come from the change being tested rather than from different questions.
Responses are then scored and grouped, which highlights weak areas such as a topic where grounding drops or a user segment that triggers unsafe answers. Teams fix the weak spots, run the set again and compare versions side by side.
| Stage | Goal | Output |
|---|---|---|
| Build evaluation set | Cover real user intents | Representative inputs |
| Run versions | Generate comparable responses | Interactions per version |
| Score and annotate | Measure quality criteria | Scores and labels |
| Compare and monitor | Choose releases, watch production | Version decisions and alerts |
Evaluating Retrieval-Augmented Generation
Retrieval-augmented generation adds a second failure point: the retriever may surface the wrong documents even when the model itself writes well. Evaluating grounding against retrieved context separates retrieval problems from generation problems, so fixes land in the right component.
Logging the retrieved passages alongside each answer is essential. Without that context, a hallucinated answer and an answer faithfully based on a poor document look identical in a simple review.
Comparing Application Versions
Version comparison answers the question every release raises: is the new prompt, model or retrieval setting actually better? Comparing scores on the same evaluation set reveals trade-offs, for example improved relevance paired with longer, less focused answers.
- Keep the evaluation set stable while comparing versions.
- Review a sample of changed answers manually, not only averages.
- Record which model, prompt and settings each version used.
Monitoring LLM Responses in Production
Real users ask questions that no test set predicted. Monitoring production interactions with the same evaluation properties shows when quality slips, when new topics appear, or when a provider-side model update changes behavior without any code change on your side.
Privacy deserves early attention here. Decide which interaction data may be logged, remove personal information where required, and confirm hosting and retention options with the vendor before sending production traffic to any evaluation service.
Getting Started with the LLM Product
The LLM evaluation offering is a hosted product with its own documentation, client SDK and account setup, separate from the open-source testing library on GitHub. Review the official LLM documentation for current onboarding steps, supported integrations and pricing details before planning a rollout.
Building a Strong Evaluation Set
Evaluation quality depends heavily on the inputs you test. A set built only from easy, typical questions will hide the failures that matter, so mix common requests with edge cases, adversarial prompts and questions your application should politely decline.
- Sample real user queries, with personal details removed.
- Add expert-written questions for critical topics.
- Include prompts that should trigger refusals or safe answers.
- Refresh the set as new user intents appear.
Common Evaluation Mistakes
Teams new to LLM testing often change several things at once, which makes it impossible to tell which change caused an improvement or a regression. Change one variable per version whenever practical and record it clearly.
Another frequent mistake is relying on averages alone. A small overall gain can hide a serious drop on an important topic, so always look at results grouped by topic, user type or document source.
Who Should Own LLM Evaluation
Evaluation works best as a shared responsibility. Engineers maintain the pipeline and logging, domain experts define what a good answer looks like, and product owners decide which trade-offs are acceptable before a release goes live.
- Engineers: data capture, version tracking and automation.
- Domain experts: annotation guidelines and edge cases.
- Product owners: release criteria and risk tolerance.
Frequently Asked Questions
The LLM evaluation product is documented as a separate hosted offering. The open-source GitHub library focuses on tabular, NLP and computer vision validation.
Yes. Grounding against retrieved context is one of the main evaluation angles described for retrieval-based applications.
Yes. Automated scoring scales evaluation, but reviewing a sample of changed answers keeps the criteria aligned with real expectations.
Production monitoring of interactions is part of the described workflow, so quality changes can be detected after release.
Conclusion
Deepchecks LLM evaluation gives teams a repeatable way to judge generative AI quality before and after release. Build a realistic evaluation set, score versions consistently, watch grounding closely for RAG systems and keep monitoring production traffic so regressions surface early.
Evaluation is never finished, because users, models and documents keep changing. Treat your evaluation set as a living asset and revisit it with every significant release.